Total Pageviews

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Response to responses

1st response

I felt like Sarah's response to "My Papa's Waltz" was a very well thought out response which talked about many different issues and, at least in my opinion, responded and discussed each issue thoroughly and deeply.  She really went into each individual topic and talked about all the different sides of the issue talking about why each issue is relevant and gave examples supporting each idea.  For the most part also she did a good job of being as little bias as possible

2nd response

Another blog post i really liked, and that i thought was very interesting, was Tomin's response to "Please don't take my air jordans".  What i liked about it so much was that it displayed his opinions and thoughts on the poem.  Usually, when people talk about pieces of literature (including myself) just kind of brief over about what they thought on it and get into some big ideas about it.  Tomin on the other hand laid it all out to, he told you exactly what he thought of it and backed it with examples from the poem and other ideas.

3rd response

The third poem I really liked and I thought was very well written was Julia's response to "Please don't take my air jordans".  The reason why I liked Julia's response so much was because you could tell she really put a lot of time and effort into making.  And I really appreciate that sort of thing.  Lots of people, including myself again, just try to do the bare minimum and leave it at that.  Julia went above and beyond what she was supposed to do.  She talked about and discussed each little thing and each idea in the poem and I liked it a lot